Is innovation stagnating in social media?

Is innovation stagnating in social media?

Christian Sharp

Christian Sharp

In August, there was uproar in the social media world over Instagram’s new ‘story’ feature. Not because it was unusable, not because it was amazing – but because it replicated what Snapchat had been doing since October 2013. For the unfamiliar, stories allow you to chain together images into a slideshow, showcasing your day, month, year or whatever you want.

According to reports, Instagram stories have seen solid success, but I suspect – rather like Facebook’s multiple attempts to introduce ephemeral messaging (i.e. time-limited, again like Snapchat) the social networks are all trying to provide users with extra value and struggling to innovate. Although Facebook might be seen as the ‘grandpa’ of the social networks today, it has a major innovation trump card in its ownership of VR headset Oculus Rift.

But it does raise the question – will the convergence of functions across social media networks render them all identical and indistinguishable in time? After all, whether you’re a Facebook messenger or a WhatsApp-er (or both), a Flickr addict or a top Instagrammer, a Snapchat fiend or a member of the Twitterati, a lot of the networks seem to do the same thing.

However, for many people, it’s about the community and spirit of the network, and the basic function of it (picture sharing, social events, instant updates) rather than the tweaks and twiddles that are introduced along the way. Sure, there are things we’d love the networks to do (LinkedIn, please introduce post scheduling ASAP) but most people generally understand what the major networks do and know people on there.

After all, almost by definition, you probably wouldn’t join a social network where you didn’t know anyone. But at the same time, function does to some extent determine form: the ephemeral nature of Snapchat makes it a young, quick-fire social network, whereas the slow-moving professional orientation of LinkedIn attracts a smart, older audience. You don’t see many people posting photos of their Friday night drinks on LinkedIn – and the same is true for Flickr, despite it being an image-based network. Flickr is more aimed at ‘artsy’ or ‘serious enthusiast’ photographers, with people showcasing their best work there.

Yet, in theory, you could put your Friday night photos on either LinkedIn or Flickr, or almost any network. Social networks develop character partially based on their function and partially based on how people use them.

It’s a strange concept but also an interesting one – and one we’ve seen historically as well. Myspace prolonged its lifespan* by a few years by focusing more on the music community, when – in all honesty – its’ functionality was more suited to being a generalist network than a musical one; more Facebook than SoundCloud. But whether the decision to be music-focused was user- or brand-determined, it certainly worked. It also took some time for Snapchat to be known as being ‘not just for nudes’, but this was certainly a combination of brand activity and user activity.

This answers our main question in a way – whilst social networks have their own communities, their own visual identities and user experiences, their functions are all reasonably similar and are growing more similar. However, the people using them will continue to subvert the function and purpose of the social networks, in much the same way as people use, misuse and adapt all the other tools we come across today.

This isn’t new – people have subverted tools and environments since man first adorned the walls of caves with paintings of his prey. But I’m sure that, like primeval man, we’ll certainly see a few beasts die out in the social networks before we move onto our next stage of development.

* We’re aware that Myspace still exists, but given that it was purchased in 2005 by News International for $580m, and then by Specific Media and Justin Timberlake for $35m in 2011, the nails are in the coffin.

Share this story:

Read more from the blog


The Leadership Paradox: Why Talent isn’t Always Enough

Talent and leadership go hand in hand in making an organisation poised for success, but one can’t do without the other. When we think about leadership, we will all have something different in mind. However, the purpose of all leaders is the same: to unite people as a team to work towards the same goal. […] ...Read more

Megan Dennison
Megan Dennison

The devil wears (preloved) Prada: Tech and second-hand marketplace growth

When I was young, my dad used to bid on second-hand kids’ jewellery for me on eBay. I’d jump up with excitement when he won an auction, but I’d also wonder – what is this strange and mysterious corner of the Internet, where we could buy silver bracelets from nondescript profiles? That corner has since […] ...Read more

Alexandra Kourakis
Alexandra Kourakis

Strategic PR planning – how to prepare for the summer slowdown

In the world of PR, and in many other industries, the beginning of each year starts with a bang. There’s a flurry of activity as companies race to make noise with new announcements, fresh messaging, the latest thought leadership and more. Then, in the second quarter, many companies host their own conferences and events. Then, […] ...Read more

Rebecca Graham
Rebecca Graham


  1. 3 Ways “Legacy Media” Navigates Social Media – The Ryan Page Blog
    3 Ways “Legacy Media” Navigates Social Media – The Ryan Page Blog

    […] point, the way to have a strong following is to be accessible. I saw a blog post recently called “Is Innovation Stagnating in Social Media”. It is an interesting read but one of the conclusions they draw is that all platforms are […]

Add a comment

Time limit exceeded. Please complete the captcha once again.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Is it time to shape your reputation?

We operate in London, Paris and Munich, and have a network of like-minded partners across the globe.

Get in touch

Sign up to Spark, our newsletter

Receive thought pieces from our leadership team, views on the news, tool of the month and light relief for comms folk

You can unsubscribe at any time, please read our privacy policy for more information